Metro Manila, Philippines — A senior trade official said he could not account for the gap between Cale88 Foods Corporation’s declared sales and the larger amount of inflows cited from Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) records during Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial on Friday, Nov. 20.
Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo told senator-judges that Cale88 declared ₱208 million in sales from 2022 to 2025. Senator-judge Win Gatchalian, however, cited AMLC records showing about ₱776 million in total inflows to the company.
Separately, AMLC executive director Ronel Buenaventura had testified during the prosecution’s presentation that Cale88 received ₱319.33 million in remittances from mainland China and Hong Kong. These are ₱315.94 million from mainland China and ₱3.39 million from Hong Kong. Three transactions were flagged as suspicious for lacking apparent legal, trade, or economic justification.
Senator-judge Joel Villanueva also asked Rodolfo about a reported ₱193.95-million remittance from Chinese company China National Township Enterprise to Cale88.
Rodolfo said that if the transaction was true, the company would have accounted for almost all of Cale88’s declared sales over the three-year period.
“Kung sakaling totoo man po ‘yon, ibig sabihin po ay halos siya lang po ‘yung kliyente dahil ang sales po ng Cale88 ay ₱208 million over the three years as declared po sa amin nung kompanya,” Rodolfo said.
[In case that is true, it means that it could be the sole client since the sales of Cale88 were ₱208 million over the three years as declared to us by the company.]
Asked by Gatchalian about the discrepancy between the company’s declared sales and the AMLC figure, Rodolfo said he found no basis in the documents submitted to the Board of Investments (BOI) to explain the higher inflows.
“In relation po sa operations ng kumpanya at saka sa sinubmit nila samin na dokumento, wala ho ako makitang rason para tumaas po sila ng more than dito sa declared sales revenue po nila na sinubmit sa amin,” he said.
[In relation to the company operations and documents submissions, I don’t see any reason for their declared sales to go higher than the revenues they submitted to us.]
Rodolfo said Cale88 submitted bank certifications covering $721,283 in foreign exchange earnings for 2023 and 2025, equivalent to ₱41.83 million using the ₱58:$1 exchange rate cited during the hearing.
However, the company did not apply for value-added tax zero-rating in 2024, leaving the BOI without corresponding bank certifications for that year. Rodolfo said Cale88 had reported about ₱150 million in export sales for 2024.
He also acknowledged that the BOI relied on documents submitted by the company and did not independently verify actual exports through shipping or customs records. He said the Bureau of Customs could provide records to establish whether the goods were exported.
Rodolfo said the BOI does not normally inspect a company’s operations unless something prompts it, such as a request for a certificate of good standing. Cale88 sought the certificate in 2026, prompting an inspection in May.
He added that Cale88 had not declared other sources of income to the BOI that could explain the difference. The company’s treasurer, operations officer, president, and export sales manager would be in a better position to explain the transactions, he said.
Meanwhile, Rodolfo confirmed that Cale88 remained registered as a micro, small, and medium enterprise. He said the company’s business plan submitted to the BOI indicated a production capacity of about 1.18 million kilograms of bananas.
Senator-judge Risa Hontiveros noted that producing more than 422,000 kilograms of banana chips could require an estimated 1.6 million to 2 million kilograms of raw bananas. She asked whether the company’s factory and workforce could support that volume.
Rodolfo said he could not personally assess the facility’s capacity because he had not seen the workplace.
“Di ko kasi nakita factory kaya ako mismo di ko masagot,” he told the senator.
[Translation: I haven’t seen the factory myself so I couldn’t answer.]
Cale88 registered with the BOI as a new export producer of banana chips in December 2021 and reported starting commercial operations in January 2022.
Based on company submissions to the Trade Department, its reported workforce grew from 115 employees in 2023 to 201 in 2024, before dropping to 50 in 2025. However, its general information sheet submitted to the corporate regulator only showed two employees.
The May 2026 BOI inspection also revealed changes in the company’s ownership and officers. Rodolfo said the agency asked the new officials to update its records.
The company’s 2024 general information sheet listed Manases Carpio, the vice president’s husband, as president and a 47.5 percent shareholder. Cale88 submitted a request to change its ownership records in July 2026.
In a post-trial press conference, the prosecution panel pointed out that the defense has yet to directly address the allegations under Article II, namely unexplained wealth, false declaration of Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth, and failure to divest businesses.
“I think there are only two possibilities… Maybe it has something to do with the competence of the defense team, or is the case of the respondent really indefensible?” Luistro said.
Defense spokesperson and lawyer Michael Poa, meanwhile, said Cale88 was not part of the allegations concerning unexplained wealth but the defense nevertheless chose to address the company because it had drawn public attention in recent weeks.
“While we have to make it clear na hindi siya part nung allegations talaga sa unexplained wealth, pero ‘yun kasi ‘yung namamayagpag the last few weeks. So we felt the need to address that, para malaman din talaga ng ating mga kababayan kung ano ba talaga itong Cale88,” Poa said.
The defense presented Food and Drug Administration director IV Marilyn Pagayunan next, who testified on the product registration of Cale88’s sweetened banana chips. She clarified that monitoring the company’s actual operations was not part of her responsibilities.
Before the trial began, the court ordered Duterte spokesperson Paolo Panelo to explain his allegations against senator-judges, on a motion of Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo.
The impeachment court canceled the Nov. 26 and 27 hearings after the defense said its witnesses were unavailable. Proceedings are scheduled to resume on Dec. 1, from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.















