Home / News / Senator-judges grill defense expert witness

Senator-judges grill defense expert witness

Rainer Dela Fuente testifying as an expert witness of the defense team on Vice President Sara Duterte's unexplained wealth on Nov. 19.

Metro Manila, Philippines – The legal team of Vice President Sara Duterte attempted to chip away at the prosecution’s chief argument—a forensic report on financial and corporate transactions—in the unexplained wealth charge through an expert witness, but senator-judges questioned its usefulness in helping them decide on the impeachment case, not to mention that the testimony was about money laundering, which is not at issue in the trial.

The defense presented Rainer dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) financial investigator, before the Senate Impeachment Court on Thursday, Nov. 19, to challenge the report of Alex Cabrera summarizing the prosecution’s evidence accusing Duterte and her husband, Manases Carpio, of amassing more than ₱817 million in unexplained wealth.

The witness, who has since set up his own law group and is also a consultant with groups on anti money laundering issues, admitted on questioning by senator-judges that he had not read the financial report, was commenting based only on portions of the report chosen by the defense, and on hypothetical situations based on the limited knowledge he has on the issue.

Defense lawyer Mark Vinluan confirmed that Dela Fuente was not given a copy of the report and would only be asked about it in open court on Day 44 of the impeachment trial.

Presiding Officer Chiz Escudero ruled that money laundering was not included in the charge of unexplained wealth, false declaration of Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net worth (SALN), and failure to divest business interest, and that the testimony only serves as an opinion on money laundering and gave leeway to the defense. 

Resurrecting the dead

The defense came under fire for showing video clips of two deceased officials from an impeachment trial 15 years ago—Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago and Chief Justice Renato Corona. There was also a video of former President Rodrigo Duterte discussing the possible impeachment of then-Vice President Leni Robredo.

It said the videos showed that government investigative agencies, including the Anti-Money Laundering Council, could be used for political persecution.

Escudero ordered the video stopped after some colleagues questioned its relevance.

“Pagpahingahin na po natin ‘yung namayapa [Let the dead rest]. That is a different case, this is a different case,” Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo said.

Senator-Judge Risa Hontiveros said it was unfair to the people shown in the videos, their families and the impeachment court, as the two could no longer be questioned.

Senator-Judge Panfilo “Ping” Lacson reiterated the intent of the provision—debated on by Sen. Vicente “Tito” Sotto III, among others, in the anti-money laundering law—to balance financial oversight with the protection of legitimate trade, commerce and bank secrecy against prohibited disclosure tied to political persecution during an election campaign.

House prosecutors, meanwhile, accused the defense of appealing to sympathy instead of directly addressing the evidence against Duterte.

Undeclared wealth findings

Dela Fuente, who heads AML Consulting PH, questioned the attribution of income and assets from corporations linked to Duterte and her husband.

He explained that corporations have a separate legal personality from their shareholders, so their assets and income should not automatically be treated as the personal assets and income of the people behind them.

Without a court ruling allowing the “piercing of the corporate veil of fiction” principle, he said only amounts actually received by the individuals, such as dividends, should be attributed to them.

Dela Fuente said the assumptions and computations in Cabrera’s forensic report raised doubts.

The defense questioned Cabrera’s estimate of the couple’s investment in five Jollibee franchise branches in Davao City, which relied on information from the company’s website which showed that a franchise could cost at least ₱35 million to ₱55 million per store.

Cabrera’s report used the minimum estimate of ₱35 million for one branch and attributed 20 percent of that amount to Duterte shares.

Dela Fuente said reviewing information online or through documents should be supplemented by onsite or fieldwork, though he acknowledged he had no personal knowledge of methods applied in the report.

He also questioned the use of store receipts to verify franchise costs, saying, “We don’t do this sa financial investigation [in financial investigation],” and pointed to government records, including certified true copies of Securities and Exchange Commission documents, as more reliable sources.

The defense also questioned the report’s treatment of a ₱10.6-million FWD Insurance purchase, which it said was attributed in full to the couple despite the report identifying transfers from two other individuals and proceeds from an investment as sources of the funds.

Dela Fuente said the registered owner of a property is generally considered its owner, although his answer did not establish who ultimately funded or owned the insurance policy.

The defense also presented the SALN of President Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. and Robredo, both of which listed business interests. Dela Fuente, however, said such disclosures alone were not adverse and would need to be examined alongside other information.

Expertise under scrutiny

Despite the defense team’s extensive establishment of Dela Fuente’s professional background and experience, senator-judges and the prosecution questioned his expert opinion.

Senator-judge Joel Villanueva asked if Dela Fuente was furnished with Cabrera’s report on Duterte’s unexplained wealth.

“If I heard it right from the witness that he himself did not even get a chance to actually read the forensic report,” he said. “I’m just wondering because if he is to refute the report, then he should have seen the report.”

Senator-judge Bam Aquino asked the witness if he was provided court records to preview, such as bank statements and general information sheets of companies relevant to the trial.

Dela Fuente repeatedly answered no, prompting Aquino to ask, “None? Okay, so I take it the defense is asking you about the report in terms of concepts?”

Vinluan confirmed this, stating that the document was 50 pages long and the defense only wanted to focus on portions.

Tulfo raised a similar concern: “Kahit nanggaling pa siya diyan sa AMLC… kung hindi naman niya po pala nakita pala ‘yung mga dokumento… what good is it? Ano pong itetestigo niya, puro po ito theory sa kanyang paningin…”

[Translation: Even if he came from the AMLC… if he didn’t even view the documents… what good is it? What is he going to testify on, these are all theoretical from his perspective…]

He then challenged the defense team to do better and present a witness who can “stand up.”

Dela Fuente, upon questioning by Hontiveros on the same issue, maintained he was relying on the law for his opinion.

Hontiveros asked if he would consider a possible misrepresentation on Cabrera as a fellow expert on the financial matter. Dela Fuente said he has high respect for him, but it’s only a matter of abiding by the law and the methodologies Cabrera used for his analysis.

“I don’t need to read the full report even before going here, because kahit i-flash po ‘yan ngayon pa lang—makikita niyo na po e, align po ba ito sa provisions ng AMLA o hindi,” Dela Fuente added.

[Translation: I don’t need to read the full report even before going here, because even if you flash it (on the screen), you’ll know immediately if it aligns with AMLA’s provisions or not.)

Given his straight answers about the forensic report on questions from the defense lawyer, House prosecutor Chel Diokno traced the witness’s career background, pointing out he only had 25 months of experience as a financial investigator at AMLC, from July 2015 to August 2017, before he was reassigned to the technical services staff for an information campaign role.

Diokno also raised the fact that he did not preview other court evidence nor Cabrera’s analysis before testifying on the trial. Dela Fuente said the documents were confidential and he was not “the intended end-user” of those files.

“You have made a variety of opinions about the report of Atty. Cabrera, about the methodologies employed. But you have no personal knowledge of what exactly was done by Atty. Cabrera in preparing this report?” the prosecutor asked. “So ano ngayon ang bigat ng inyong opinion kung wala naman pala kayong alam tungkol sa mga ginawa ni Atty. Cabrera?”

[Translation: So what’s the weight of your opinion if you are not aware of Atty. Cabrera’s analysis?]

Dela Fuente remained firm on basing only from the law, particularly the AMLA, and that he personally chose not to view any documents prior to the trial to avoid bias or be “swayed” by the report.

Meanwhile, Duterte spokesperson Paolo Panelo claimed “bias” on the part of the senator-judges.

Defense counsel Michael Poa, however, said in a separate interview that the defense team respected the court’s inquiries and it did not feel rushed during questioning from senator-judges.

He added that it was a conscious decision not to provide Dela Fuente court documents as he asked to maintain independence before the trial.

The trial resumes on Friday, Nov. 20, with the defense presenting three more witnesses.

ADVERTISEMENT
Tagged: